Skip to content

the stress additionally comes (and above all) from Europe

For Gabriel Attal, the Minister of Public Accounts, the chance was too good to cross up. Whereas the Senate voted this weekend, an modification on pensions offering for elevating the authorized retirement age from 62 to 64, the Macronist minister reiterated this Monday on BFM the federal government’s full intention to hold out the reform . Gabriel Attal noticed within the senatorial vote – nearly all of which is on the correct – a constructive signal: that of acquiring a potential majority on this explosive topic. At Bercy, Bruno Le Maire additionally defends this line. The Minister of the Economic system has lengthy pleaded the necessity for pension reform. Definitely, for the second, the federal government is not going to maintain this modification of the senators, preferring to proceed the session with the unions. However, in accordance with Emmanuel Macron’s needs, he nonetheless has his sights set on the adoption of a speedy reform: presentation of a textual content in early 2023 for entry into software subsequent summer season.

Pension system: is France actually an exception?

A budgetary necessity for the manager however not solely…

For most of the people, the monetary argument is repeatedly put ahead by the manager to lift the beginning age in France within the personal sector to 64 years outdated. Based on a examine by the Treasury, the acquire in income can be 12 billion euros from 2027 – i.e. the cash that might come into the coffers by way of pension contributions – and the financial savings made, – on much less pensions to be paid, and so on. – , can be round 8 billion euros on the identical date.

However one other much less audible component for public opinion largely comes into play to encourage the federal government to carry its line: stress from our European companions. “The pension reform is a big marker for them, they’re ready for France to evolve on this topic”, assures a minister. And so as to add: “The French exception of leaving at 62 annoys them a lot. And that is nothing new. In Germany, already, on the time of Angela Merkel, the Chancellor despatched the message to Paris as quickly as she may: the French should work longer”.

As a reminder, in three quarters of the international locations of the European Union, the retirement age reaches or exceeds 65 years. Lately, most European governments have carried out tough reforms with their fellow residents, not with out developing towards social opposition.

The truth is, “France seems to be lagging behind, lax, lazy, idle”, continues one other influential member of the federal government. And to confide: “Particularly since annually, roughly talking, we are saying in Brussels that we’re going to speed up the motion, then we come again to our dedication … as a result of one yr, there are the yellow vests, one other, it is covid, then inflation…they’re dropping persistence”. Within the doc that Paris despatched this summer season to Brussels, France has additionally promised to hold out two essential reforms: that of unemployment insurance coverage, about to be adopted, and that of pensions…

The stress of our first financial accomplice: Germany

Thus, Germany is within the entrance line to ask France to maneuver up a gear. It have to be mentioned that throughout the Rhine, the Germans work longer than the French. They hardly ever depart earlier than 65, the authorized retirement age, which might be raised to 67 by 2029.

Final spring, three influential German economists – Bernd Raffelhüschen, Stephan Kooths, and Gunther Schnabl, even recommended elevating the retirement age to 70, specifically to “take up the shock of inflation”, which in Germany exceeds 10 %.

And for good cause, in Germany too, the query of financing is an explosive topic. With an growing old age pyramid and a low start charge, the nation must get better cash. In June 2021, an impartial report from the Ministry of the Economic system estimated that the necessity for pension financing may characterize 45% of the state funds, in comparison with 1 / 4 in 2019.

If Chancellor Olaf Scholz doesn’t plan to evaluation the 67-year-old threshold instantly, for worry of social unrest because the recession looms in Germany, he’s much less and fewer tolerant of France’s wait-and-see place.

At a time when the Franco-German couple is struggling, when Germany is wanting extra in the direction of the US or China, this topic of pensions may due to this fact play the irritant within the pillar couple of the Union. On the event of the G20, which is being held this week in Bali, the Chancellor is not going to fail to remind Bruno Le Maire or Emmanuel Macron of the dedication made by France on this file.

However the French nonetheless upset towards a reform

In the meantime, in French public opinion, the thought of ​​suspending the age to 64 is much from unanimous. Within the polls, there are solely retirees – due to this fact those that usually are not involved by a potential reform, and who’re primarily fearful in regards to the quantity of their pensions – who say they’re in favor.

Unsurprisingly, the unions proceed to indicate their hostility. Sunday November 13, Philippe Martinez, the chief of the CGT warned: he guarantees essential mobilizations if the federal government shifts the age of departure. Even for employers, retirement is (now not) the first concern. Enterprise leaders are extra open to the federal government to toughen unemployment insurance coverage guidelines – to facilitate recruitment and cut back tensions over labor shortages, or to helps pay hovering vitality payments that threaten manufacturing.

Regardless of the insistence of our European companions, nonetheless, the capsule guarantees to be tough to cross. In a context of inflation and diminished buying energy, households might not settle for the extra effort that might be required of them to work longer.