Skip to content

The organized flight of worldwide aviation • Pivot

local weather transport

The Worldwide Civil Aviation Group (ICAO) opens its triennial common meeting this Tuesday, September 27 by camouflaging and denying its personal accountability for the continued local weather disaster, accuse two organizations which intently comply with the actions of this United Nations company. United based mostly in Montreal.

“The monstrous fires and disastrous floods of the previous couple of months show it: the local weather disaster is tangible…and the expansion in air site visitors is simply making it worse,” writes Mira Kapfinger, coordinator of Keep Grounded, a community made up of 233 teams scattered throughout all continents, in an electronic mail trade with Pivot.

“The ICAO Meeting is not going to talk about the required discount in air site visitors and doesn’t even take into consideration all of the emissions [de l’aviation] that alter the local weather, as revealed by its official paperwork analyzed by Keep Grounded. […] ICAO’s local weather technique is pure greenwashing. »

Transport & Setting (T&E), a Brussels-based group that brings collectively some fifty NGOs campaigning for accountable transport insurance policies, denounces the carbon offset mechanisms put ahead by the ICAO to make individuals consider that it’s in search of cut back the impression of aviation on the local weather.

“ICAO’s local weather technique is pure greenwashing. »

Mira Kapfinger, Keep Grounded Coordinator

“ICAO, this United Nations company with a mandate to cut back world aviation emissions, makes use of a system of buying carbon credit that has thus far confirmed to be utterly ineffective in lowering the impression aviation local weather,” mentioned T&E in an announcement issued on the eve of the 41e Meeting.

An evaluation carried out by T&E reveals that on a flight between Europe and the USA, passengers will on common solely need to pay 2.40 euros ($3.16) extra to offset their carbon emissions. carbon, and that not earlier than 2030.

The phantasm of carbon credit

An evaluation of the agenda of the 41e meeting reveals that ICAO focuses its local weather technique on technological effectivity and on its CORSIA programme, or Carbon Offsetting and Discount Scheme for Worldwide Aviation.

Transport & Setting calls the CORSIA program a fraud, whereas Keep Grounded speaks of a inexperienced phantasm.

It is window dressing, retort the organizations Keep Grounded and Transport & Setting. Sure, planes devour much less and fewer kerosene. Nevertheless it permits them to fly additional, sooner and extra cheaply, so in the long run they fly extra, carry extra passengers and pollute extra.

This well-known “Jevons paradox” is clearly seen on our roads: due to technological enhancements, automobiles devour much less gasoline per kilometer, with the outcome that producers are promoting SUVs slightly than small automobiles.

Transport & Setting calls the CORSIA program a fraud, whereas Keep Grounded speaks of a inexperienced phantasm.

Mainly, the ICAO makes consider that it’s potential to offset the impression of flights by shopping for carbon credit. The few further {dollars} that the airplane tickets will ultimately value could be used, for instance, to plant bushes, fairly often within the southern hemisphere. However earlier than a small tree shops the three tonnes of carbon equal emitted by a spherical journey from Montreal to Paris, it would take many years… if, within the meantime, it doesn’t burn or is just not reduce down.

Carbon credit score packages should not solely utterly ineffective – being topped with success in 2% of circumstances in keeping with a German analysis institute –, however they are often detrimental to native populations in southern nations, pressured to offset emissions. made by the privileged within the nations of the North.

The injustice is flagrant. It’s the wealthiest fraction of humanity that takes the airplane.

In some circumstances, “small landowners and indigenous populations are prohibited from utilizing the forest in keeping with their ancestral habits, with a view to retailer carbon within the bushes in predefined portions”, emphasizes Keep Grounded.

“In sum, the compensation is unfair and quantities to a type of carbon colonialism. To permit a small a part of the world’s inhabitants to fly continuous whereas sustaining ecological conscience, sure populations should pay the worth: these are sometimes these whose emissions are already very low, whose historic contribution to local weather change is negligible, and who furthermore are already having to cope with the impacts of the local weather disaster. »

Urgency to behave

The 41e session of the ICAO Normal Meeting begins because the world has by no means been extra conscious of the gravity of the local weather disaster. This Saturday, September 24, Hurricane Fiona was unleashed within the Atlantic provinces. Winds blowing as much as 177 km/h ravaged the coasts, destroying about twenty homes in Channel-Port aux Basques, Newfoundland, and inflicting monumental harm to the Magdalen Islands and the Maritimes. The power of this storm is defined specifically by the warming of the ocean waters.

Through the summer season, Europe, the western United States, China, Pakistan and a number of other different areas skilled an unprecedented succession of warmth waves, droughts and floods. Final summer season, drought precipitated a pointy drop in agricultural yields on the Canadian prairies. The good famines, which we thought had been a factor of the previous, are coming again to hang-out us, particularly in Somalia.

This with solely a one diploma Celsius enhance in common temperature. Nonetheless, we’re heading in direction of a rise of three.2 ohC by the tip of the century. To totally perceive what this seemingly small quantity means, let’s examine it to a everlasting fever of 40 ohC and extra in a human being…

In a report tabled in September, the Secretary Normal of the World Meteorological Group, Petteri Taalas, stresses that it’s essential to multiply by seven the commitments to cut back greenhouse gases by 2030 if we need to respect the Paris Settlement, aiming to not exceed a rise of 1.5 ohvs.

This identical report questions in diplomatic phrases the ambivalence of the aviation sector on this regard, in addition to the “ambiguities” inherent in carbon credit score packages.

Dramatic resumption of flights

ICAO welcomes the resumption of air site visitors, which plummeted through the pandemic. This site visitors doubles each fifteen years. The Air Transport Motion Group (AGAG), one of many lobbies representing the airline trade, predicts a rise of three% per yr over the subsequent 20 years.

This enhance goes hand in hand with a gradual rise in greenhouse fuel emissions from the aviation sector. In its inner paperwork, the ICAO mentions solely CO2 emissions – about 2% of the whole – nevertheless it ignores different GHG emissions, reminiscent of nitrogen oxides, the soot that blackens sea ice and contrails. condensation that traps warmth. In whole, aviation is chargeable for virtually 6% of worldwide warming.

The injustice is flagrant. It’s the wealthiest fraction of humanity that takes the airplane. It’s estimated that lower than 5% of human beings fly every year. Between 80% and 95% of people is not going to have taken it as soon as of their lifetime.

The rise in air site visitors goes hand in hand with a gradual enhance in greenhouse fuel emissions from the aviation sector.

A single spherical journey from Montreal to Paris has a local weather impression equal to three.2 tons of CO2 – whereas a Ugandan solely emits 1.1 tons per yr on common. The typical CO2 equal emissions is 4 tons per inhabitant on earth. If we need to stop the local weather from warming greater than 1.5 ohC, emissions needs to be reduce in half by 2030, to achieve a median of two tonnes per inhabitant.

Canadian rapper Drake’s private airplane, full with luxurious bogs, emits twice as a lot in a 14-minute flight from Toronto to Hamilton.

Montreal, world capital of aviation

By taking the airplane for his or her pleasure or for his or her enterprise, the wealthiest human beings thus worsen the climatic disaster to the detriment of the poorest. It is a uncooked fact that nobody desires to listen to, particularly not in Montreal, the world capital of civil aviation, residence of the primary trade foyer (the Worldwide Air Transport Affiliation, IATA) and of Bombardier, a of the primary producers of personal jets, which is at all times demanding extra subsidies from governments.

It’s also a fact that the ICAO doesn’t need to acknowledge, but a United Nations company, whose Secretary Normal, Antonio Guterres, multiplies the warnings towards the “collective suicide” that world warming constitutes.


Journalist André Noël, contributor to Pivot and Radio-Canada, commented on the agenda for the 41e Normal Meeting of ICAO on situation Every part can occur from Saturday 24 September.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *